Fresh Fuel Import Battle Emerges After Abuja Court Ruling
Nigeria’s fuel-import debate has entered a new legal phase after a Federal High Court in Abuja ordered the petroleum regulator to continue issuing and renewing import licences for three oil marketers.
The judgment has reopened questions about the place of imported petrol in a market where domestic refining capacity is expanding rapidly.
Justice Inyang Ekwo directed the Nigerian Midstream and Downstream Petroleum Regulatory Authority to continue granting, extending, renewing or reissuing import licences to Matrix Energy, A.A. Rano Nigeria Limited and AYM Shafa Limited, provided the companies meet all relevant legal and regulatory requirements.
The court held that the NMDPRA’s previous refusal to grant or renew the licences was inconsistent with provisions of the Petroleum Industry Act, 2021.
The three marketers had approached the court seeking clarification on whether the PIA allowed the importation of petroleum products and whether the regulator could issue licences to qualified importers.
They also argued that the NMDPRA had a duty to promote competition within the midstream and downstream petroleum industry.
Justice Ekwo agreed, holding that the PIA and relevant provisions of the Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Act require the regulator to promote competition and prevent restrictive practices.
The judgment also declared that the three companies remained eligible to obtain petroleum import licences after fulfilling the conditions prescribed by the regulator.
The court’s decision has now become another point of contention in the disagreement over how Nigeria should manage fuel imports as more locally refined products enter the market.
Dangote’s case adds to dispute
The Abuja decision comes as Dangote Petroleum Refinery pursues a separate legal challenge at the Federal High Court in Lagos.
Dangote Refinery is challenging the continued issuance and renewal of petroleum import licences to the Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited and several other marketers.
The refinery is asking the Lagos court to invalidate licences it alleges were issued or renewed around May 6, 2026, for NNPC and companies including NIPCO, A.A. Rano, Matrix, Shafa, Pinnacle and Bono.
Dangote also contends that some of the disputed licences were issued despite an earlier court directive requiring parties to maintain the status quo.
The Lagos court has fixed October 7 for the hearing of the suit.
The fact that the two disputes are being considered by courts of coordinate jurisdiction has added another layer to the fuel-import controversy.
The Abuja judgment does not automatically determine the outcome of Dangote’s case in Lagos, but the two proceedings are examining related questions about petroleum imports, regulation and competition.
Importers defend access to market
Petroleum marketers have welcomed the Abuja judgment, arguing that maintaining multiple sources of supply could help prevent shortages and improve competition.
The Petroleum Products Retail Outlets Owners Association of Nigeria said the judgment was beneficial to consumers because it supported supply diversification.
Its National President, Billy Gillis-Harry, argued that import licences should not be restricted only to the three companies involved in the Abuja suit.
He said any company with the capacity to import petroleum products and meet the applicable requirements should have access to the market.
According to him, having different sources of supply could help improve product availability and affordability.
The Independent Petroleum Marketers Association of Nigeria also said the judgment should be respected.
Its National Publicity Secretary, Chinedu Ukadike, said marketers would consider both imported and locally refined products based on price and supply conditions.
He said marketers would buy from domestic refineries when their products offered competitive prices and would consider imports when imported products were more affordable.
Debate over domestic refining
The court ruling has also intensified arguments over whether Nigeria should allow imported fuel to compete with products from domestic refineries.
Some industry stakeholders believe unrestricted imports could make it harder for local refiners to compete, particularly after heavy investments in new refining capacity.
Others argue that removing import competition could expose consumers to higher prices and create conditions for market dominance.
An energy expert, Dan Kunle, called for changes to the Petroleum Industry Act, arguing that lawmakers did not anticipate the emergence of a refinery of Dangote’s scale when the legislation was drafted.
Kunle said the government should review the law to reflect Nigeria’s current refining capacity and economic circumstances.
He argued that fuel imports should be allowed mainly when domestic production is insufficient rather than becoming a permanent feature of the market.
According to him, the government needs to balance legal compliance with broader economic interests.
Refinery owners seek reduction in imports
The Crude Oil Refinery-Owners Association of Nigeria has also called for a gradual reduction in petrol imports.
Its Chairman, Momoh Oyarekhua, said Nigeria should take advantage of its growing refining capacity instead of continuing to depend heavily on imported petroleum products.
He pointed to the difficulty some domestic refineries face in obtaining crude oil at commercially viable prices.
CORAN has called for greater implementation of the Domestic Crude Supply Obligation under the Petroleum Industry Act and improved access to crude for qualifying local refineries.
The association also wants the naira-for-crude policy to be fully implemented, with transparent access for domestic refiners.
Oyarekhua argued that reducing imports would allow Nigeria to retain more foreign exchange, create jobs and increase the amount of economic value generated within the country.
He also proposed that imports eventually be limited to situations where domestic supply is unable to meet demand or where additional products are required for strategic reserves.
Marketers urge caution
While the legal and policy arguments continue, IPMAN Vice President Hammed Fashola urged industry players to prevent the court disputes from affecting fuel distribution.
Fashola said taking disagreements over the interpretation of the Petroleum Industry Act to court was legitimate.
He, however, stressed that litigation should not lead to disruptions in the supply of petroleum products.
He said the various parties still had opportunities to appeal decisions through the judicial system or resolve their differences through discussions.
Fashola urged Dangote Refinery, importers, regulators and other stakeholders to ensure that their disagreements did not create shortages or undermine stability in the downstream market.
A market at a turning point
The latest court battle comes as Nigeria’s fuel market undergoes a major transition.
For years, the country depended heavily on imported refined petroleum products because its government-owned refineries operated below capacity or remained inactive.
The emergence of large-scale private refining has changed that picture.
However, the continued availability of import licences means imported products remain part of the market.
The disagreement now centres on whether that competition should continue without restrictions, be gradually reduced or be limited to periods when domestic refineries cannot meet national demand.
For marketers, competition provides an alternative source of supply.
For domestic refinery operators, sustained imports could undermine investment in local refining.
For the government and regulator, the challenge is to balance those competing interests while complying with existing law.
The Abuja judgment has therefore moved the argument beyond the question of individual import licences and back to a bigger issue: how Nigeria should regulate its petroleum market as local refining capacity expands.
With Dangote’s case still pending in Lagos and the Abuja ruling potentially subject to further legal proceedings, the dispute over fuel imports is far from settled.
SHARE